Memorandum 14-016 Acceptance of Bronze Bust of Brother Asaiah
TO: MAYOR WYTHE AND CITY COUNCIL
FROM: PUBLIC ARTS COMMITTEE
THROUGH: RENEE KRAUSE, CMC, DEPUTY CITY CLERK
DATE: JANUARY 13, 2014
SUBJECT: ACCEPTANCE OF DONATION OF ARTWORK – BRONZE BUST OF BROTHER ASAIAH
Local artist Leo Vait was commissioned to create and sculpt a life-size bust of “Brother Asaiah”. Mr. Files and Ms. Martha Anderson are acting as local representatives for the person wishing to remain unrecognized and or anonymous.
The WKFL Park was donated by Brother Asaiah to the city. Within the selected location there is a rock with a dedication plaque and it is here that the proposed bronze bust would be placed. It is intended to be a permanent placement and will be attached by the appropriate means.
All required documents have been submitted and copies are included for your review.
At a special meeting on January 9, 2014 the Public Arts Committee deliberated and heard public testimony against the idea of a sculpture and or placement in WKFL Park. Following is the excerpt from the minutes of their discussion and ensuing motion:
A. Donation of Commissioned Artwork for Placement within WKFL Park
1. Gift Proposal Form
2. Pictures of Proposed Art Donation
3. Resume of Artist
4. Artist Previous Works
5. Photos of Asaiah Bates
6. Letters of Support
Vice Chair Miller read the title into the record. Ms. Krause noted this started with an inquiry from Ms. Otteson.
Ms. Otteson stated that she was contacted regarding the commissioned sculpture, stating that approval was desired before further work was done on the sculpture and submittal to the foundry. Ms. Otteson felt that it should go before the Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission since it was being requested to be placed in a city park. She contacted Ms. Krause who notified her about the process in place for donating works of art to the city.
Chair Newby expressed appreciation for Ms. Otteson and the City Manager for their support of the protocols; she stated that she received emails with photos from Mr. Will Files.
Discussion ensued on the cost of the artwork and what the procedure was regarding the donation application. Chair Newby provided a summary explanation on the background of the application and recalled the donation of the bench as a memorial for the Eagle Lady. Vice Chair Miller stated that it still did not explain the process on what the committee should do now. Ms. Aplin stated that while the idea of the donation is acceptable, it is apparent that the venue may not be acceptable.
Commissioner Lowney was permitted to offer her comment stating that this item was on the Parks and Recreation Commission agenda next week and she believed that due to the conflict on the appropriateness of the suggested placement in WKFL Park that they provide more opportunity for the public to weigh in, she further opined that she understood the concern expressed by Mr. Landfield regarding the overcrowding of the park but she had less concern on that since it would be installed on top of an existing rock, technically it is not taking up space.
The committee discussed the need for further opportunity for a public hearing; that Brother Asaiah was a very unassuming man; why this project needed fast tracking through the process and making a quick decision. The committee expressed concern on the venue being appropriate. It was determine that Council was the appropriate forum to get the word out to the public.
Vice Chair Miller requested a motion. Ms. Krause requested a few minutes to draft the appropriate motion for the committee.
APLIN/NEWBY - MOVED TO RECOMMEND THAT THE DONATION OF THE SCULPTURE WOULD BE ACCEPTABLE TO ADD TO THE MUNICIPAL ART COLLECTION HOWEVER THERE IS A QUESTION REGARDING THE LOCATION BEING APPROPRIATE AND THEREFORE RECOMMEND CITY COUNCIL HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE ISSUE. FURTHERMORE, THE COMMITTEE WOULD ALSO RECOMMEND CITY COUNCIL INCLUDE THE RECOMMENDATION FROM THE PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING ON JANUARY 16, 2014 IN THEIR DELIBERATIONS.
There was no further discussion.
VOTE. YES. NON-OBJECTION. UNANIMOUS CONSENT.
Hold a public hearing to obtain more public input on the acceptance and placement of a life-size bronze bust of Brother Asaiah in WKFL Park.